1. Overall Wrestler of the Year
I'll give this one to The First. There could be some real debate as to whether Stevens or The First had the better year, but through it all, I think 2010 was really summarized in The First rising over the Stevens wave that's pretty much dominated the federation for the past two years. The rivalry held between these two served to deliver The First as the World Champion, which is why he gets the Wrestler of the Year Overall bid.
2. Face of the year
I'll be different and say Karl "The Dragon" Brown was the Face of the Year 2010. The story was great: foundation member of old-school Empire Pro returns to the ring and picks up right where he left off setting a standard and capturing the TV Title. Brown's character really delivers in not getting caught up in overdone storylines, but still generating some energetic and emotional matches.
3. Heel of the year
"New School" Layne Winters really delivered this year as the new bad kid on the block. His success garnered a run with a championship and generated some heated rivalries.
4. Tag Team of the Year
Heirs of Wrestling almost feel like the only team that qualifies here. The Anthology had some strength near the beginning, but seemed to gas out right around the time the Tag Titles changed hands. Though they haven't had much to work with, the Heirs of Wrestling have kept things pretty interesting with their ensemble cast of characters.
5. Show of the Year
I don't think anything will out-do Sin City Showdown any time soon. The sheer epic-ness of that event will stand for at least a couple years. Great matches, and great main events, with every star in either federation in their prime.
6. Angle of the Year
Copycat's war against Empire Pro really stood above all else in its longevity. The story really grew too, with Cat's heat with Dan Ryan building to the point where even the senior official's son got involved - I really enjoy the use of NPCs. The story only gets better as the ex-World Champion Stevens gets involved, and really, it leaves me interested in seeing what the future brings.
7. RP Thread of the Year
Black Dawn's 2010 Main Event has a massive 36 replies from some of the best e-wrestling talent the world has to offer. If this were the real thing, they'd have to release these promos on a DVD 2-Disc set, with Mike Neely and Cameron Cruise doing color commentary.
8. Match of the Year
The match to the thread above. Does anybody remember, did I write it? I can't remember this **** sometimes...
9. Rookie/Newcomer of the Year
Michael Bastard. The character just arrived and has been a wrecking ball ever since.
10. Book the championships for the end of 2011 (ie. who will be TV champ, World champ, Tag champs by the end of 2011.)
World Champion - Karl "The Dragon" Brown - I think this is the year he arrives, but only after a hard-fought four-way with The First, Anarky, and Layne Winters
Intercontinental Champion - Copycat - After a year-long reign as IC Champ, Michael Bastard will finally cave in to the psychological warfare instilled by Copycat, who turns even the cunning Amazing Logan against his own talent. Of course, it will be a ladder match
TV Champion - Stalker - With extreme experience in his arsenal, Stalker will come out ahead of other hot contenders such as Donovan Astros and Dopesmoker to claim the TV Title
Tag Team Champions - The Cameron Cruise Project V2.0 - To the surprise of everyone, Cameron Cruise will return to the tag scene with "TRIPLE X" SEAN STEVENS as his partner in a newly modified "Melton-free" version of the CCP, overcoming the challenges of the Heirs of Wrestling and the Colossal Connection.
I could probably write out the rest of the year, but it'd take me until 2012